the tao of jaklumen

the path of the sage must become the path of the hero

Dilemma of the Hollywood Ingenue?


I went to the store early in the wee hours of this morning to pick up a few food items.  Coming to the checkout, I couldn't help but browse the tabloids.  Sure, I know it's junk, but I'm always curious to see how they're butchering the celebrities and serving them up like potted meat products.

One of the photos on the cover– I think it might have been the cover of People magazine caught my eye.  My immediate thought was, "So this is the recent flap about Britney Spears?  She looks voluptuous."  I mentioned it in passing to the checker, who was obviously fresh on the graveyard shift.  The look on her face was a mixture of disbelief and disgust.  (Obviously, she was not aware that some odd folks like me will strike up a conversation or two.)

"You like that?"

"Well, no…"

It just went downhill from there.

Here's one of the media photographs (cropped a little bit)– judge for yourself:

Spears reportedly said she "looked like a fat pig."  How about "I'm still skinnier than Marilyn Monroe was"?  Indeed, the sex symbol of yore is now too fat for the American public.

Oh, how the mighty have fallen.  I really think she's been trapped by the machine– the Hollywood machine.  She's one of the graduates of the Mousekeeter Club, although I think she's been targeted because unlike Justin, Christina, and a few others, she had a child… and didn't handle it well, or at least the way the public expects.

She seemed to be set up as the classic celebrity ingenue– the girlie girl who is very nice, but has a naughty side.  She was in sharp contrast to her immediate colleague Christina Aguilera, who attempted to shatter that mold but suddenly realized that the public might soon crush her as a scamp.  No, Spears was seemingly pure, but available as the male fantasy of the woman you could probably take home to Mom without too many problems.

She got married, had a child, and got divorced.  I figure some people perceived that as threatening.  How dare they take away their fantasy!  To make matters worse, I think some started dredging up wholesome expectations reminiscent of her Disney past– and she failed– miserably.  "Oops, I Did It Again"?  Dropped her baby.  Drove with her baby in her lap.  So she swung like a pendulum.  Shaved her head (so sexy hair is gone).  Then she starts clubhopping with another Disney grad, Lindsey Lohan, but also with the bubble-headed socialite everyone loves to hate (and maybe secretly envy), Paris Hilton.

The last part I think is justifably criticized–  Britney chose the family life, but decided to revolt against it, living like a single woman– but not a single mom.  But do I care whether she's wearing underwear or not?  Nope.

Some writers have said the public loves to prop celebrities up to tear them down later.  I don't think it's as simple as that.  I think the public starts tearing them down when they see they've been deceived, or find out that they no longer fit the image they were initially given.  For example, Martha Stewart is a shrewd businesswoman, but she cannot be considered The Everymom Homemaker/Gracious Hostess in a strict regard.  Harrison Ford is not Indiana Jones or Han Solo in private– he's actually very soft-spoken and somewhat reserved.

Sadly, I think this is leveled more at women celebrities than male ones.  Disdain for irresponsible moms, I can understand.  But the dysfunctional idea that moms cannot be sexy, especially the ones that are measured against traditional standards, I don't understand.  Full-figured changed from ample curves to 'fat', supposedly.  That, I believe, is wrong.

Read and post comments | Send to a friend

Author: jaklumen

Wherever you see "jaklumen", that's me- the username is still unique as of the current year. Be aware that the facet you see, is only a small part of the me that is me.

2 thoughts on “Dilemma of the Hollywood Ingenue?

  1. When I first saw people online making comments about her weight I was livid (still am).I cringe to think about defending Britney Spears, but her body looks fantastic. I wouldn't even go as far as considering voluptuous, she's downright thin. Most women, with and without children have more belly than that (and rightly so, it's how we're built!).I think you've made a very good point in your second to last paragraph. It's sad that people don't realize from the start that all the articles in the world can't paint an accurate portrait of a person. Yet everyone is so quick to judge as if they actually know the person.


  2. Yes, the entire situation is sad. The "cult of celebrity," the body image issues, all of it. I feel esp bad for the little girls who are trying to grow up to be young women, when this kind of thing is going on. I grew up when Marilyn Monroe (and others like her – and doris Day,etc. ) were celebs- stars – but that model of womanhood was never QUITE assumed to be realsitic. Not really. Little girls might hope for curves and try to organize them via clothing, but I think we all just knew that stars were not like us- we weren't expected to be like them. Not sure how it works now– but from what i hear, many kids have trouble living up to what they see in magazines and on TV.


Walk with me, talk with me. Leave a reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s